Does this look like a real sperm? Do you believe in UFO's?
Published yesterday in the journal Stem Cells and Development, this is being hailed by the press as “breakthrough” research. Now call me cautious, or call me a stem cell biologist, but I get suspicious when that term is used to describe medical research. More on that later. The technique, discovered by a team of biologists at the University of Newcastle in England and led by Dr. Karim Nayernia, purports to have created actual moving sperm from human embryonic stem cells. Not in a testicle, but in a laboratory dish. This group has some amount of “street cred” as they had previously published a paper in which mouse embryonic stem cells were used to produce in a dish. In fact, these sperm were injected into mouse eggs, formed mouse embryos and baby mice. However, a close look at the small print reveals the mouse pups all had “growth abnormalities” and died after birth.
Now back to being Mr. Cautious. If you look closely at the figures and video in the human paper, you might not be convinced that these are actual sperm. Pictures are a little too fuzzy. Kind of UFO-like. Could they really be neurons instead of sperm? Also, the sperm neither look nor move quite like what we would expect with normal sperm. Finally, some of the “reporter” genes that are used to classify the genetic origin of the cells are not working all that perfectly. Why didn’t the researchers provide more convincing evidence of the universally recognized elements of a sperm including the acrosome, midpiece with mitochondria and characteristic axonemal structure? Oh, and where are the controls?
There is no doubt that Dr Nayernia will face scrutiny for this work, as he has before. And this is all good. Because if the scientific world believes that it is true, then this is an amazing feat of science with enormous potential. For such acceptance to occur, a confirmatory study by another group will likely be necessary. Maybe ours, as we are investigating the same concept but in a radically different and much more feasible way—by trying to create an entire artificial testicle instead.
There are other meaty issues surrounding this research. Is it safe? Is it practical? Remember how inefficient it was to clone Dolly the lamb? Inefficiency runs rampant in any reproductive process. As an example, say that you discovered that humans can reproduce through sex and tried to license the process. With a 20% efficiency rate, you would probably be denied the license. On the other hand, if it is really true, this work has demonstrated the enormous potential of embryonic stem cells, as making a sperm is about as complex a process of cellular transformation that you will find in the body. Making bone, cartilage or heart cells should be much easier. Will it ever get to the point in which a healthy child might be conceived in this way? If that happens, then I might start thinking more about the real role of man in mankind. But not sooner. After all, if men become redundant in the reproductive process, who will replace men’s uncanny knack for opening jars?
Tags: Add new tag, Assisted Reproduction, male infertility, men's health, reproduction, sperm, sperm count, stem cells, testicle
UPDATE: So, Mr. Cautious won out here: The Nayernia paper discussed in this blog was RETRACTED or WITHDRAWN from publication by the Publisher. This happened quickly too. This means that the publisher doubts its truth and now refuses to publish the work. May good science always win! PJT
Prescription Drugs – Evista…
Does this look like a real sperm? Do you believe in UFO’s? [...]…
Nice site!
Other variant is possible also
Evista…
Does this look like a real sperm? Do you believe in UFO’s? [...]…
A lot of good information here, fantastic layout too.
important post , really good view on the subject and very well written, this certainly has put a spin on my day, numerous thanks from the USA and sustain up the good work
Nice post..Keep them coming
Thanks for sharing.
Hello!!! turekonmenshealth.com is one of the most excellent resourceful websites of its kind. I enjoy reading it every day. I will be back.
yeah, this is a good website keep it up
I’ve made updated my website template check it out i would appreciate it Arabic Girls names
Great post, You make valid points in a concise and pertinent fashion, I will read more of your stuff, thank you for your time. one of my articles hope u enjoy reading free online paid surveys
Hey! I admire your writing and the way you explain things. Some of the comments on here too are insightful. I appreciate you. keep it up!
Great information! Thanks!
Interesting, never thought of it like that
de beste autoverzekeringen voor nog geen 30 euro in de maand?het is mogelijk kijk hier!
Hi, I have been visiting your site for a while, and wanted to ask you a question if I may. I’ve just set up my site and looking for ways to advertise my blog in the search engines, as I’ve been receiving some profitable traffic from the search engines and want to increase it. I have been looking at what this blog says about link building and SERP’s in Google ht tp://webmasters-tools.info/i/linkbuilding.php I’ve learnt the more links I have to my blog, the higher my place in Google it will be. But I was just wondering if other website owners in the same genre as us have been following it, and if you would recommend it? I would sincerely appreciate your opinion, as I’m in two minds whether to go ahead. Thank you very much 8o)
This was a nice post! I am looking for some related pictures. Anybody got some good ones?
Nice site to visit! I admire your writing and the way you explain things. Some of the comments on here too are insightful. I appreciate you. keep it up!
The new fertility tratment is surprisingly good, but soem argue not as good as the icsi sperm ijections. It works well, but isn’t as fast, and has a funky yet positive ratio of success. If you occasionally plan on using the hormones or supplements that’s not an issue, but if you’re planning to browse the web alot for infertilty solutions look no furhter than fertilityleader.com.
Have you got any recommendation for when I do use this?
Just thought you’d be interested to know that I have added you to my bookmarks You make valid points in a concise and pertinent fashion, I will read more of your stuff, thank you for your time. one of my articles hope u enjoy reading take surveys get paid
I am glad that I ran into your site on Bing. I really enjoyed your article. If you are interested in swapping links with each other’s sites, let me know. I’d be happy to get on each other’s blogrolls. Here is my site: How To MIG Weld.
Will this work for both men and women?
Nice work.